Eyes closed as they were, Ash quite literally didn't see the slap coming. He was too wrapped up in the sensation of Eli's dick in him to notice anything else right then.

He didn't even make a sound when the strike came down, just a sharp faint gasp, eyes going suddenly wide and tensing like a vise around Elijah's cock. All of it an utterly raw reaction, no chance or time to fake anything.

"Fuck, Eli-" he'd bitten his tongue and his words were a little slurred from it. "Warn a guy!"

If the way his erection hadn't flagged in the slightest, the complaint was entirely empty.